> 1 <

Author Message

CrawlingChaos

Premium Cone


Online status

98 posts

Location: United States
Occupation:
Age: 38

#9995   2007-01-21 14:14 GMT      
I am an artist and I would like to start working with some of the computer programs out their. I would like use an Adobe product, but I am unsure what the differences are between Illustrator and Photoshop. With the name illustrator, I would assume this would be the logical choice, but from what I gather, alot of artist seem to prefer Photoshop. Can anyone recommend which would be better in my case? Please don't recomend one mainly based on price, only it's merits. I am willing to spend any amount of money, but if possible I would only like to purchase one product.

Steve

Senior Cone


Online status

537 posts

Location: United Kingdom Northern Ireland
Occupation: Student
Age: 19

#9996   2007-01-21 14:31 GMT      
I think it depends on the kind of artwork you are doing.
I think illustrator is better for graphic art and photoshop is better for images--photos, scans.
I use Photoshop. It is a powerful program with much to offer.

jm
www.motzkin.com

spllogics

Moderators


Online status

316 posts

Location: United States PA
Occupation: Designer
Age: 26

#9997   2007-01-21 14:40 GMT      
I use photoshop. To put it simply It is more like drawing on paper, if you are using the brush tool.

Illustrator is used more for vector work, and shifting the lines to your liking isn't going to happen.

RollTheStones

Premium Cone


Online status

113 posts

Location: Canada
Occupation:
Age: 16

#9998   2007-01-21 15:07 GMT      
photoshop is more a picture software and it uses pixels- this is what you would use if you are doing pictures, scanned images, or low end graphics
illustrator is more of a graphic software it uses vectors (lines) instead of pixels- this is a program for high end graphics and makes everything very clean cut

if you are wanting to free hand images instead of graphics photoshop is better
if you want high end graphics illustrator is better

i find photoshop easier to use but illustrator gets easier with use

Lassie

Rookie Cone


Online status

379 posts
http://www.artworld.si
Location: Grenada
Occupation: Egyptologist
Age: 38

#9999   2007-01-21 16:03 GMT      
In my opinion, drawing in Photoshop takes a little "getting used to" compared to Illustrator. I do, however, prefer Photoshop over Illustrator since I am a genetically artistic and can incorporate photographs of my own fine art work into my computer art.
If you have free time, click the link below to find tutorials on both programs. The tutorials are availble all over the internet, but I really like this one. You can look through some of the tutorials for "effects" to see what fits your own personal style. Then, by looking at what others have created, you can decide which one to buy. They are both excellent programs but if you aren't looking to make a career out of graphic design you will need to decide which program has the biggest potential to benefit your own, natural style-it will more than likely be Photoshop.
Greetings. I am Lassie, your friendly ArtWorld mascot.

PhotoMom25

Premium Cone


Online status

125 posts

Location: United States
Occupation:
Age:

#10000   2007-01-21 17:25 GMT      
Laura

View my new BLOG

FMyth

Moderators


Online status

219 posts

Location: Canada
Occupation:
Age: 23

#10001   2007-01-21 18:34 GMT      
Type is a real issue between the two softwares. Use of type for design in photoshop is a no-no, as they do not come out as sharp as in Illustrator or InDesign.

Photoshop is mainly for use with photographs, Illustrator for drawing and graphic design.

InDesign is the industry standard now for graphic layout work, replacing old school Quark software.

I personally, still use photoshop more than any of the other softwares, because of it's color correction features, filters, opacities, styles and brushes. I just find it more versatile. I only use the other two mainly for type.

I hope this helps.

FMyth

Moderators


Online status

219 posts

Location: Canada
Occupation:
Age: 23

#10002   2007-01-21 18:38 GMT      
Dude, save your money and try Dogwaffle first. This is a freeware product for illustrators that has many of the same brushes and effects as Adobe. If you can handle this then you can either upgrade to their pro version or go ahead and buy the name brand ones later.

I would also advising getting a tablet & pen. Mine is by Wacom; it also comes with a wireless mouse (which I actually prefer because the drawing surface is too small for me working with the pen)

BrownSugar

Premium Cone


Online status

137 posts

Location: United Kingdom
Occupation:
Age: 38

#10003   2007-01-22 09:36 GMT      
I use both and like both. If you do painterly type work then go with Photoshop. It is the best out there.
Illustrator is great if you are doing more graphic work.
I suggest you got to adobe and download there free trials of each software.
If you want one that does it all I would suggest going with Photoshop.
And if money is no object get both!
http://www.adobe.com/products/creativesuite/
You get it all and more in that package!
> 1 <
 
Subscribe To Photoshop Tutorials Via RSS!

Or...

Get New Tutorials Through Email! For Free!

Sign up for our free newsletter and get the highest quality original tutorials delivered to your inbox! Never miss a new tutorial again!

Email:
First Name:

Your email will never be sold or given to anyone! We hate spam as much as you do!